| Old-Time Hockey Achievement Award |
 |
| Congratulations John Kelleher |
|
|
| Season |
Player |
Player |
| 2019 - Winter |
John Kelleher |
|
| 2019 - Spring |
Cooch |
|
| 2018 - Winter |
Ray Dow |
|
| 2018 - Spring |
Jim Barber |
|
| 2017 - Winter |
Gary Goodwin |
|
| 2017 - Spring |
Joe Shannon |
|
| 2016 - Winter |
Kellie Abcunas |
|
| 2016 - Spring |
Tony Mastrocola |
|
| 2015 - Winter |
Jeff Deharo |
|
| 2015 - Spring |
Tony Bono |
|
| 2014 - Winter |
Mike Hollingsworth |
|
| 2013 - Spring |
Scott Young |
|
| 2012 - Winter |
Matty Ianello |
|
| 2012 - Spring |
Jim Clarke |
|
| 2011 - Winter |
Doug Sidille |
|
| 2011 - Spring |
Mike Naczas |
|
| 2010 - Winter |
Mike Luise |
|
| 2010 - Spring |
Pat Pirone |
|
| 2009 - Winter |
Jim Miner |
|
| 2009 - Spring |
Dave Miner |
|
| 2008 - Winter |
Ray Nickerson |
|
| 2008 - Spring |
Steve Oppedisano |
|
| 2007 - Winter |
None |
|
| 2007 - Spring |
Dave Hill |
|
| 2006 - Winter |
Nick Romano |
|
| 2006 - Spring |
Ed Dullea |
|
| 2005 - Winter |
Bill Mack |
Mark Stickney |
| 2005 - Spring |
Ed Nigro |
Mark Micale |
| 2004 - Spring |
Dan Broderick |
|
|
|
|